A declassified CIA document titled "Possible Fallibility of Polygraph Testing of Subjects in Posthypnotic States" explores whether a person under the influence of posthypnotic suggestion could beat a lie detector test.
The implications are chilling-particularly when applied to interrogation, espionage, or counterintelligence.
Written in 1954, the report reveals that U.S. intelligence agencies were seriously considering the potential to train individuals to bypass polygraph tests through posthypnotic amnesia and induced false memories.
"It would appear possible that a subject could avoid [lie detector] reactions… if he were interrogated while in a posthypnotic state."
🧪 The Limits of Lie Detection
Polygraph machines are designed to pick up physiological changes-heart rate, sweat gland activity, respiratory shifts-when a person lies. But what if a person didn’t believe they were lying?
The memo outlines how hypnosis could be used to:
-
Instill false recollections that overwrite real ones
-
Induce amnesia about key facts or events
-
Create emotional defenses against re-hypnotization or interrogation
-
Maintain psychological calm when discussing events they’ve been trained to forget
In short, someone could theoretically pass a polygraph while recounting a completely fabricated story, believing it to be true.
🧍 Case Study: Theft Without Guilt
The document references experiments where subjects were hypnotized, told to steal money, and given amnesia about the order. When questioned days later, they showed no guilt-no signs of deception, and no awareness that they had committed a crime.
In one example, a female subject stole money from a stranger after posthypnotic suggestion.
When confronted later, she was "righteously indignant," sincerely believing she hadn’t done it.
This, the document notes, poses a serious challenge: how can you detect deception when the subject genuinely believes the lie?
"The subject’s reactions to other questions… would probably be normal."
🧠 Personality, Control, and Training
The CIA also considered the variability of individual hypnotizability-some people are more susceptible than others. To reliably weaponize this method, an agency would need:
-
Rigorous selection of suitable subjects
-
Intensive psychological training
-
Deep understanding of individual responses to trance and suggestion
The ultimate goal was to create a subject who could self-hypnotize or be triggered into a suggestible state with a specific cue, then perform an action-possibly even criminal-without conscious memory or guilt.
❌ Detection Seemed Unlikely
Despite extensive study, the report concludes that detecting whether someone was in a posthypnotic state during a polygraph was effectively impossible.
The absence of conscious awareness meant no physiological stress signals-rendering traditional lie detection tools blind.
"Detection of the posthypnotic state by polygraph… seems unlikely."
🕳️ A Glimpse into Deep-State Mind Control Fears
This memo is not science fiction. It’s a real Cold War document, outlining real government concern that hypnosis could undermine the foundational tools of security and justice.
It doesn’t confirm success-but it does confirm the effort. The CIA was preparing for a future in which the mind could be manipulated so thoroughly that even the body’s involuntary responses could no longer be trusted.
