A declassified trove of internal FBI communications reveals a decades-long institutional push to purge its own historical records, some dating as far back as 1920.
This wasn’t the careful curation of archives. It was bureaucratic incineration.
Documents contained in FOIA release 1356897 paint a picture of an agency obsessed with order, secrecy, and the ability to erase the paper trail.
“It is believed this material can be destroyed,” reads one 1944 memo, referring to correspondence sent between field agents during Prohibition-era operations.
The justification?
No one had asked for it - yet.
🕯️ The Purge Began Quietly
In a 1931 memo signed by FBI Director J. Edgar Hoover himself, the Bureau launched what it described as a “study” of old files in field offices across the country.
The outcome was unambiguous:
“All files over ten years old… should be transmitted to the Bureau at the Seat of Government. If duplicate copies exist, destroy the originals.”
This initiative didn’t just mean cleaning house. It meant centralizing control - and systematically removing any material deemed ‘non-essential.’
One inspector estimated that more than 100,000 case files would be destroyed under this plan.
🔥 A Bonfire of Bureaucracy
Transportation records included in the release show that 20 large containers of reports were physically moved from various FBI facilities to a centralized incinerator at 7th and B Streets NW in Washington.
“Also one box and 10 sacks from the garage at 21st and L Streets,” one 1938 memo reads.
Once destroyed, no public record was kept - except for internal lists buried in closed memos.
“These are purely administrative… never requested… no index cards,” the Bureau rationalized.
What was lost?
Letters between special agents.
Field notes.
Administrative memos from the early 20th century.
And possibly clues to investigative methods long buried.
🧠 Memory vs. Management
Not everyone agreed with the destruction strategy.
In 1938, FBI analyst D.E. Balch warned that discarding “abstract slips”-internal index cards used to reference major cases like Hamm, Bremer, and Lindbergh-was sabotaging institutional memory.
“It would appear nothing should be destroyed which would assist in quickly finding material,” Balch argued.
Despite his concerns, most index records were destroyed after three years unless someone intervened.
🧾 Congress Steps In (Too Late?)
By 1932, Department of Justice lawyers began to worry that mass file destruction violated federal law.
“No files may be destroyed without submitting a list to Congress,” one legal review warned.
Yet internal memos show the FBI continued incineration operations well into the 1940s, before any congressional review occurred.
🧩 The Lost Investigations
The exact contents of the destroyed files may never be known. But based on what little metadata survives, these purged archives likely included:
-
Early 1920s surveillance records on political groups
-
Correspondence from FBI agents regarding organized crime
-
Price controls and Fair Commission enforcement logs
-
Files on suspected communists, union leaders, or civil rights activists
-
Operational blueprints for regional offices during Prohibition
These were not just clerical records. These were snapshots of the American security state in its formative years.
🗝️ Why This Still Matters
In an era where government accountability remains front-page news, the revelation that the FBI intentionally erased massive amounts of its own history - with little oversight - is both sobering and illuminating.
This wasn’t digital deletion.
It was manual, methodical obliteration.
“If no request has ever been made,” one memo rationalized,
“the material can be destroyed.”
In a digital age where nothing is truly deleted, this story reminds us: Some secrets were burned before they were ever archived.
